FitBits
Exercise ETC's Monthly Research Review
October 15, 2007
Compiled by Chris Marino, MS, CSCS
Director of Education, Exercise ETC
Creatine
Supplementation
Increases Muscle Mass
in Older Adults
"Sarcopenia" is to muscle as "osteoporosis" is to bone. The age-associated decline in muscle mass becomes pathological when it reaches 2 standard deviations below the average peak muscle mass that is attained at around the age of 30. It’s estimated that functional impairment due to sarcopenia affects a quarter of adults over age 75.
Although resistance exercise is the best method for increasing lean mass across all age groups, gains in lean mass are dependent on hormones, such as testosterone, which facilitate anabolic activity. Levels of anabolic hormones are substantially lower in older adults than in younger adults, thereby delaying increases in muscle hypertrophy that would occur with resistance exercise alone. Due to the urgency presented by conditions such as sarcopenia, researchers are seeking alternative ways to augment the effects of resistance exercise on muscle hypertrophy in older adults. Creatine may be one such alternative.
A recent study assessed whether creatine monohydrate and conjugated linoleic acid would increase lean body mass, decrease fat mass, and increase strength when used in combination with resistance exercise in older adults. Thirty-nine men and women between the ages of 65 and 85 participated in 6 months of resistance training while supplementing with creatine monohydrate and conjugated linoleic acid. Researchers measured muscle strength & endurance, a variety of performance-based tasks, body composition and other markers.
The results were positive. Although resistance exercise alone improved functional capacity and strength, greater improvement in endurance, strength and lean mass as well as lower fat mass, were observed in the creatine monohydrate and conjugated linoleic acid group. In this study, the combination of creatine monohydrate and conjugated linoleic acid did effectively augment the increase in lean mass associated with resistance exercise.
It’s important to note that this is the first known study to evaluate use of creatine monohydrate and conjugated linoleic acid along with resistance exercise in the older adult population, and that further studies should be published before any recommendations can be made to the public. As always, fitness professionals should use caution before recommending nutrition supplements to clients, and any client wanting to use any supplement should be advised to speak with a registered dietitian or a physician first.
Tarnopolsky, M. (2007) Creatine monohydrate and conjugated linoleic acid improve strength and body composition following resistance exercise in older adults. PLoS ONE. 2(10): 991.
Can
Static Stretching
Actually Improve Performance?
Static stretching has become quite controversial in performance training over the past decade. Research has reported that there are no apparent injury reduction benefits for pre-exercise stretching and some speculate that static stretching could actually increase injuries in sports that are explosive in nature because of decreased force potential in a muscle that’s been stretched for as little as 15 seconds. Interestingly, a recent study published in Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise now suggests that de-conditioned populations may experience performance gains with static stretching alone.
Thirty-eight participants were randomly assigned to stretching and control groups. The stretching group participated in lower-extremity static stretching 3 days per week for 40-minutes over 10 weeks. No other exercise activities were permitting during this period. Researchers assessed flexibility, explosive power via 20-meter sprint, standing long jump and vertical jump, strength via 1RM testing for knee flexion and extension, and strength endurance via total repetitions at 60% 1RM in knee flexion and extension.
Although flexibility did improve 18% over the course of the study, what surprised researchers was the significant increase in performance measures. Among tests of power, standing long jump, vertical jump, and 20-meter sprint participants all improved. Strength improved 15.3% for knee flexion and 32.4% for knee extension, whereas knee flexion endurance and knee extension endurance increased 30.4% and 28.5%, respectively. Controls showed no improvement in any of the variables assessed.
The results of this study indicate that static stretching might benefit individuals who are not capable of participating in a traditional exercise program. This may explain some of the perceived strength benefits attained when a deconditioned individual starts a yoga program. Athletes and other well-conditioned populations are not expected to see similar benefits.
Kokkonen,
J. et al (2007) Chronic static stretching improves exercise performance.
Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise. 39(10): 1825-31.
Is
Soy Protein
As Effective as Whey Protein?
The combination of resistance exercise and adequate protein intake is essential for increasing lean body mass. Although optimal protein sources are derived from whole foods, supplemental protein is popular because it is convenient and effective in providing the essential amino acids necessary for building muscle. Supplemental proteins are typically divided into two categories: soy products and milk-based (whey and casein).
Soy foods contain phytoestrogens or isoflavones, which are found to both promote and inhibit estrogenic activity. This may deter individuals from using soy-based proteins because an increase in estrogen results in reduced testosterone production. Milk proteins contain a greater number of BCAA (branch-chain amino acids) when compared to soy. BCAA’s, including leucine, isoleucine and valine have been found to have important properties in muscle hypertrophy. Unfortunately, research directly comparing the two types of protein and their effects on hypertrophy is lacking…until now.
Researchers had twenty participants ingest 50g of either Soy concentrate, Soy isolate, Soy Isolate with Whey Blend, or a Whey Blend only while on a 12-week resistance training program. Twenty-five grams were taken with 10-12 oz of water within 1 hour of resistance training. An additional 25g was ingested later during the day. Pre- and post-measures of body composition, testosterone, estradiol, and SHBG in addition to total cholesterol, LDL, and glucose were evaluated.
Interestingly, all protein sources were equally effective at increasing lean body mass. The testosterone/estradiol ratio was increased in all groups while estradiol decreased. The greatest increase in testosterone/estradiol was found in the soy isolate + whey blend group, while estradiol was lowest in the whey blend group.
In actuality, most manufacturers use a combination of milk and soy-based proteins in their products. The researchers speculate that reductions in testosterone as a result of soy proteins may be dose dependent and that the smaller amounts in mixed protein powders is not sufficient to cause androgens to decline. There was no decline in testosterone in any of the groups in this study.
It’s important to note that the sponsors of this study included The Solae Company, which is a major manufacturer of Soy-based products. The impact of their contribution to the published results cannot be ascertained.
Kalman, D. et al (2007) Effect of protein source and resistance training on body composition and sex hormones. Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition. 4(1): 4
Low
Bone Mass
Common in Women Runners
Weight-bearing activities are known to promote increased bone mineral density (BMD), especially in women under 30. Therefore, it would be logical to conclude that the impact-nature of running would improve BMD. A recent study, however, found that intercollegiate female runners have the lowest bone mineral density (BMD) than athletes in other sports.
Researchers at Michigan State University collected data from 99 female NCAA division 1 athletes in 12 sports and compared BMD values controlling for body mass and menstrual dysfunction. Compared to all other sports, runners had lower total BMD and BMD at the pelvis and lumbar spine. Although not significantly different from runners, swimmers presented with lowest BMD in the legs.
If running is an intense weight-bearing activity that should increase BMD, what factors are voiding the projected gains? The researchers speculate that calorie intakes in female runners may be insufficient relative to the costs of higher volumes of training. They also cite the possibility of a high incidence of eating disorders and low calcium intake in long-distance runners.
The results of this study should encourage athletic trainers to be aware of the concerns for stress fractures and bone injuries in this population. Coaches and parents should address psycho-social factors that are contributing to undereating while emphasizing the need to prevent osteoporosis in youth.
Mudd, L.M., et al (2007) Bone Mineral Density in Collegiate Female Athletes: Comparisons among Sports. Journal of Athletic Training. 42(3):403-408
Introductory
Offer!
Try a Webinar for Only $10.00!
Earn
0.2 CECs or 2.0 CEUs
While You Try This New Way to Earn CEs
You've heard about our webinars but maybe you’ve been hesitant about trying one. Now's your chance! While space is available, you can try any one of our Thursday night webinars for only $10.00.
What's a "Webinar?"
A webinar is a continuing education program conducted in real time over the Internet. Just like a traditional classroom training program, you will watch the presentation on your computer while you listen to the program presenter. Have a question? Ask your instructor and hear your answer in real time, all from the privacy and comfort of your home or office. If you have a computer with a wired, high-speed Internet connection, come try one of our webinars!
No Games. No Gimmicks. No Kidding.
This offer is good only for our Thursday night Webinar series on "Exercise for Chronic Diseases and Disabilities." You must register for the webinar on our secure website only, and this offer is limited to only one $10 webinar per customer. Each 2-hour webinar has been approved for 0.2 CEs through ACE, CSCS, NSCA and NASM and 2.0 CEUs through AFAA, ACSM, NATABOCX, ISSA and more. For complete information on CE awards, click on: http://www.exerciseetc.com/cec.html
To
register for this
introductory offer, click on: http://www.exerciseetc.com/virtual.html#7
Bunny
Cotter Celebrates
10 Years with Exercise ETC!
Exercise ETC’s Director of Operations, Bunny Cotter, celebrated her tenth anniversary with the Company in September. Many of you know Bunny for her excellent customer service skills, great sense of humor and incredible attention to detail. Bunny is an integral part of the Exercise ETC family and we want to thank her for her hard work, dedication and for making work so much fun. If you would like to congratulate Bunny on this milestone, you can e-mail her at: info@exerciseetc.com
Exercise
ETC Receives
Multiple Honors This Fall
On September 29 Exercise ETC received a Special Recognition Award from the Fitness Institute International at their annual graduation ceremony and awards banquet in Boca Raton, FL. Dr. Anthony Abbott, FACSM, CSCS*D presented this award to Exercise ETC for our "highly credentialed faculty" and commitment to excellence in continuing education.
On October 11 Exercise ETC was notified that we had received "Preferred Provider" status from the American Council on Exercise. This honor was granted based on our proven record of high quality educational products and excellent customer service.
To
unsubscribe or change your options,
scroll to the bottom of this newsletter
and click on the link.
©
2010 Exercise ETC Inc.
1881 NE 26 Street # 202
Ft. Lauderdale, FL 33305
(p) 800-244-1344
(f) 954-566-3937
info@exerciseetc.com